When you’re unsure whether to stay in a relationship, a pause is usually wiser than deciding in the heat of the moment. A pause gives your body time to settle and gives you time to understand your own part in what’s happened. It also takes the pressure off a decision that deserves clarity. Discernment counseling is built around this idea. In the first published analysis of 100 consecutive cases, about half of the couples chose to start couples therapy to reconcile, and most of the rest chose the divorce path. Either way, the goal is a decision made with clarity and confidence, not out of exhaustion, anger, or pressure.

 

Why isn’t a heated moment a good time to decide?

 

It’s the same reason we ask children to take a pause when they’re fighting or overwhelmed. When we’re dysregulated, we’re not at our wisest. Our bodies are in fight-or-flight, and big decisions made from there are often driven by anger, exhaustion, or fear. Our post on the antidotes to the Four Horsemen explains why a genuine, agreed-upon break matters.

 

What does a pause make possible?

 

A pause that’s long enough lets people recognize what they’ve contributed to the relationship, so they take responsibility rather than blaming or shaming their partner. From that steadier place, a couple can choose one of the three paths of discernment counseling: stay the course, move toward divorce, or commit to six months of couples therapy.

 

Is it okay to stay in the status quo for a while?

 

Sometimes a longer pause isn’t a bad thing. One partner may need more time. Maybe their pain has lasted longer, or the partner who is leaning in hasn’t yet recognized their own contributions and the damage they caused. Sometimes it takes a little longer in the status quo before someone is ready to choose counseling or divorce.

 

That can be very frustrating for the partner who wants to work on things now. I understand. One caveat: a pause is never a reason to stay where you aren’t safe. If you’re afraid of your partner, the National Domestic Violence Hotline is available 24/7 at 1-800-799-7233, or by texting START to 88788.

 

What if you’re the one leaning in?

 

Here’s a true confession from a real therapist: I’m a hope monger. I believe in relationships, and I believe people can change. But I’ve also wondered whether, over the years, I’ve encouraged people to try harder than they should have when their hearts were telling them it was time to leave.

 

These days, my inner hope monger says something different. Give your partner time and space to make a wise decision rather than a rushed one they may regret under pressure. Don’t force counseling on someone who isn’t ready, willing, or able to show up for it. Take the pressure off, and turn your attention to your own self-reflection. What’s my part? What patterns do I bring? What do I need? That honest look inward is powerful, and it’s where discernment counseling can help.

 

If you’d like support taking this kind of pause, our couples counseling team is here. In my next post, I’ll talk about two sensitive situations: affairs and domestic violence.

 


Frequently Asked Questions

 

What does it mean to pause a relationship decision?

It means setting the big decision down for a defined period while you reflect, calm down, and understand your own part, rather than deciding in the heat of the moment.

 

Why shouldn’t you make big relationship decisions when you’re upset?

When we’re dysregulated, our thinking narrows and is driven more by anger, exhaustion, or fear. A pause helps you decide from a steadier place.

 

Is it okay to stay in the status quo for a while?

Sometimes. One partner may need more time before choosing counseling or divorce. That’s never a reason to stay where you’re not safe.

 

Should I push my partner into couples counseling if they’re unsure?

Forcing counseling on someone who isn’t ready or willing to engage usually doesn’t help. Giving space and focusing on your own self-reflection often does more.

 

Does discernment counseling lead to divorce or reconciliation?

In one analysis of 100 consecutive cases, about half of couples chose to begin couples therapy, and most of the rest chose divorce. The goal is clarity either way. Learn more about our discernment counseling.


 

Sources

  • Doherty, Harris & Wilde (2016), Journal of Marital and Family Therapy: PubMed
  • National Domestic Violence Hotline: thehotline.org

 

*Photo by Aaron Burden on Unsplash

Translate »